Guide: Unlocking the Full Potential of AI in Claims
An executive guide for claims leaders on the next evolution of AI in claims: connecting what AI understands about a claim to setting it to work moving the file within your authority limits, while your experts focus on the decisions that need judgment.
5 min read
TL;DR: Most claims AI today reads, summarizes, and drafts faster than any adjuster. The file still waits on a diary until an adjuster acts, and on a liability file that wait has a clock on it. Executive Guide: Unlocking the Full Potential of AI in Claims explains claims leaders how to connect AI’s understanding of a claim to AI making action on it with the control your operation requires, and the governance that lets you trust it.
Why faster claims tasks haven't produced faster claims
Anyone who has worked a desk knows this file. A commercial auto liability claim comes in. You receive FNOL, set up the claim, send the acknowledgment, and order the police report. The report lands on day six. AI pulls the facts out of it in seconds.
Then the file sits on a 14-day diary. In the same file, a time-limited demand from the claimant’s attorney is waiting for review.
That idle time is where the exposure lives. On a liability file it means a missed fair claims practices deadline, a DOI complaint, or a time-limited demand that expires before anyone evaluated it. Miss the wrong one and a limits case starts to look like a bad faith case.
Claims has added technology for 30 years: imaging, claims systems, rules engines, portals, and now generative AI. Each one made a task faster. Moving the file between tasks still depends on an adjuster working a full pending and a full diary.
The numbers show it. A Sedgwick report found that 82% of carriers use AI for routine tasks, while only 7% say they’ve achieved AI success at scale. Our guide calls this the claims AI productivity paradox, and puts it plainly: the intelligence is deployed, and the decisions are still queued behind a person.
What lies beyond AI summaries and recommendations
The guide separates the AI claims teams use today by how far each one goes on the file.
AI chat answers scripted questions, like claim status or where to send a document. It can’t see the claim file.
Generative AI reads and writes. It summarizes a demand package and drafts the reservation of rights letter. The adjuster still copies the output into the file, sends the letter, and sets the next diary.
Agentic AI acts within permissions you set: it schedules the recorded statement, requests the medical records, or updates the reserve within its limit. On its own, it handles one task and waits for the next trigger, so the file can still stall between steps.
AI orchestration connects them across the life of the claim. It tracks what each stage needs, watches the demand deadline, moves routine work forward, and brings the adjuster in for the coverage position, the liability call, or anything above authority. Then the routine work picks back up. That’s the full potential the guide is about.
Trust is the obvious question, and claims already has the answer. A new adjuster starts with limited authority. You review their files and widen that authority as they prove out. The same logic applies to AI: treat it like settlement authority, granted by action, line, and role, and widened one task at a time.
What you'll get from the guide
The guide is written for CCOs, VPs of Claims, and COOs deciding how far to take AI on their book and how to do it without adding regulatory or litigation exposure. Inside:
- The claims AI productivity paradox. Where files sit idle, where diaries and demand deadlines slip, and what industry data says about carriers moving AI past the pilot.
- From task automation to AI claims orchestration. A plain comparison of chatbots, generative AI, and agentic AI, what orchestration does on a liability file, and the three things an AI agent needs to keep a file moving: it anticipates the next step, understands your SOPs and documents, and acts in your claims system within authority limits.
- The AI-led claims operating model. Three stages and who decides at each: Assist, where AI recommends and the adjuster acts; Collaborate, where AI drafts actions for a named approver; and Lead, where AI runs the routine file work within written limits and escalates exceptions. Plus the split of work between AI and adjusters, and how the adjuster moves from working files to owning the decisions that need judgment.
- The business case in the KPIs you already run. Pending inventory, closing ratio, reopen rate, leakage, litigation rate, overdue diaries, and missed deadlines.
- Building trust, governance and control. Five governance principles and an enterprise checklist, including how time-sensitive demands and statutory deadlines get flagged and escalated. The guide recommends running it in a pilot on live claims.
- Your five-phase roadmap to AI-led claims operations. Five phases to start focused, deploy within defined boundaries, and expand on measured results.
Five Sigma built Clive™, its multi-agent AI claims expert, to orchestrate this work within each insurer’s SOPs, guardrails, and authority limits, on top of an existing claims system or inside Five Sigma’s AI-native CMS.
Book 30 minutes with our claims team.
See what an AI-led claims operation looks like on your book.
Frequently asked questions
What is the claims AI productivity paradox?
AI makes individual claims tasks faster, but files still sit on diaries between steps waiting for an adjuster to act, so pending inventory and cycle time barely move.
What’s the difference between generative AI and agentic AI in claims?
Generative AI reads, summarizes, and drafts, and the adjuster acts on its output. Agentic AI takes defined actions on the file, such as requesting medical records or scheduling a recorded statement, within the authority limits the insurer sets.
Does agentic AI replace claims adjusters?
No. Adjusters keep coverage positions, complex liability, settlement authority, and negotiation. AI handles the routine file work around those decisions and brings the adjuster in when judgment or approval is needed.
How do you govern AI that acts on claims?
Treat it like settlement authority: set limits by action, line, and role, log every AI action in the claim file, escalate time-sensitive demands and statutory deadlines, and route low-confidence work to an adjuster.
What should you look for in an AI claims management solution?
Look for a claims-native solution that goes beyond AI summaries to execute and orchestrate work across the claims lifecycle. It should support existing systems, enforce authority limits, maintain audit trails, and measure operational outcomes. Five Sigma’s AI-Native Claims Solutions are designed around these requirements.
Can I automate claims without replacing my existing claims management system?
Yes. AI claims automation can run on top of an existing CMS. Five Sigma’s Clive™ connects to existing claims systems, executes routine work within insurer-defined SOPs and authority limits, and escalates decisions requiring human judgment. Clive is also available natively within Five Sigma’s AI-native Claims Management Platform.
Tirtza Bensoussan
Related resources